Elsevier

Sleep Medicine

Volumes 27–28, November–December 2016, Pages 54-58
Sleep Medicine

Original Article
Impact of different hypopnea definitions on obstructive sleep apnea severity and cardiovascular mortality risk in women and elderly individuals

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sleep.2016.05.020Get rights and content

Highlights

  • We analyzed two cohorts of 1116 women and 939 elderly individuals studied for suspicion of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA).

  • Hypopnea definitions influenced OSA prevalence and severity classification.

  • The current hypopnea definition is associated with cardiovascular death in women.

  • The current hypopnea criteria are not associated with cardiovascular death in elderly individuals.

Abstract

Objective

To assess the impact of three hypopnea definitions on the severity classification of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) and its association with cardiovascular mortality risk in women and elderly individuals.

Methods

We analyzed two Spanish clinical cohorts (1116 women and 939 elderly individuals) who were studied for suspicion of OSA between 1998 and 2007. A calibration model was used to apply different definitions of hypopnea to our two cohorts. Hypopnea was defined as a 30–90% reduction in oronasal flow for ≥10 s followed by (1) ≥4% fall in oxyhemoglobin saturation—AHI4%; (2) ≥3% fall in oxyhemoglobin saturation—AHI3%; or (3) ≥3% fall in oxyhemoglobin saturation or an event-related arousal—AHI3%a.

Results

In both cohorts, the prevalence of an AHI ≥30 events/h increased by 14% with AHI3%a, compared to AHI4% criteria. The percentage of women with an AHI <5 events/h decreased from 13.9% with AHI4% to 1.1% with the AHI3%a definition. In fully adjusted multivariable analyses, AHI ≥30 events/h was associated with increased cardiovascular mortality risk in women, regardless of the hypopnea definition, and in elderly individuals diagnosed using the AHI4% and AHI3% but not the AHI3%a definition.

Conclusions

Our findings suggest that hypopnea definitions substantially influence OSA prevalence and severity classification, and also affect the association with cardiovascular outcomes. With the currently recommended criterion (AHI3%a), a threshold of 30 events/h is appropriate to identify women, but not elderly individuals with increased risk of cardiovascular death.

Introduction

Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is a highly prevalent disorder characterized by repetitive episodes of complete or partial upper airway obstruction during sleep. The apnea–hypopnea index (AHI), that is, the sum of apneas plus hypopneas per hour of sleep, is the conventional metric used to diagnose and to classify the severity of OSA. A precise definition of the events that compose this index is therefore of the utmost importance. Although the definition of apnea is clear and has not changed over the years, the scoring of hypopneas depends on several factors, such as the degree of the accompanying oxyhemoglobin desaturation (SaO2), the degree of airflow reduction, and the occurrence of an arousal. Furthermore, the criteria for scoring hypopneas have varied with successive updates from the American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) [1], [2]. These modified criteria may lead to significant changes in estimates of the AHI, which, in turn, will alter disease prevalence and possibly even therapeutic decisions. Specifically, less stringent criteria would result in a higher prevalence of moderate-to-severe OSA and increase the potential number of patients requiring active treatment, particularly in the presence of associated symptoms. For example, the use of the 2012 AASM criterion for hypopnea, which requires at least a 30% decrease in oro-nasal airflow accompanied by either a three percent decrease in SaO2 or an event-related arousal, implies that almost one-third of the subjects analyzed in a recent study could be reclassified between non-OSA and OSA categories, compared to former, more restrictive criteria (AASM 2007) [3], [4]. Recent studies conducted in either population-based or small clinical cohorts have confirmed that these changes in the hypopnea definition have led to a higher prevalence of OSA [3], [5], [6], [7], [8]. However, the impact of different hypopnea metrics on population subsets is unknown. Another concern is that variability in defining hypopneas could influence the association with cardiovascular outcomes [6]. The aim of this study was to investigate the impact of three different definitions of hypopnea on the classification of OSA severity and its association with cardiovascular mortality risk in two large clinical cohorts of women and elderly individuals.

Section snippets

Design, settings, and patients

We have analyzed two large clinical cohorts composed of 1116 women and 939 elderly individuals (≥65 years of age) who were consecutively studied for suspicion of OSA between 1998 and 2007 in two Spanish sleep clinics and were followed up until December 2009. The two cohorts were originally assembled to investigate the association between OSA and cardiovascular mortality, as well as the effect of continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) on this association. Exclusion criteria were age <18

Results

The two clinical cohorts were composed of 1116 female and 939 elderly individuals, respectively. Baseline characteristics for each cohort are shown in Table 1. The female cohort was followed up for a median of 72 months (IQR, 52–88 months) and the elderly cohort was followed for 69 months (IQR, 49–87 months). The average AHI was within the severe range with any of the hypopnea definitions used, for both cohorts, but it was significantly higher with the AHI3%a and AHI3%, compared to the AHI4%

Discussion

In two large clinical cohorts of women and elderly individuals referred for suspicion of OSA, classification of disease severity varied substantially based on the criteria used to define hypopneas. Accordingly, adopting one or other hypopnea definition would lead to marked difference in OSA prevalence and, perhaps more importantly, the therapeutic decision. Not surprisingly, different hypopnea definitions also have an impact on the association between AHI and cardiovascular outcomes. If the

Conclusions

In summary, the findings presented herein suggest that in two clinical cohorts of women and elderly individuals referred for OSA suspicion, the use of different hypopnea criteria may substantially change the severity classification of OSA in the highest-severity group in both cohorts and also in the lowest category in female patients. An AHI ≥30 events/h was independently associated with increased cardiovascular mortality risk regardless of the hypopnea definition in both groups, except in

Acknowledgment

The authors thank Dr. Valentina Isetta for her help in data analysis.

References (19)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (26)

  • Sleep Study and Oximetry Parameters for Predicting Postoperative Complications in Patients With OSA

    2019, Chest
    Citation Excerpt :

    An AHI of 30 from one laboratory may not be equivalent to that from another. The North American AASM criteria allow for two differing scoring methods for hypopneas.23,52 The criteria for decrease in oxyhemoglobin desaturation can be > 3% or 4%, which can result in variability in the AHI.

  • Diagnostic accuracy of overnight oximetry for the diagnosis of sleep-disordered breathing in atrial fibrillation patients

    2018, International Journal of Cardiology
    Citation Excerpt :

    This definition has been used in the majority of observational studies investigating the effect of sleep apnea treatment on AF outcomes [8,9]. Although recent studies suggest that an alternative, stricter AHI definition, which requires hypopneas to be associated with 4% oxygen desaturation without consideration of cortical arousals, is superior with respect to the assessment of cardiovascular risk [18,29,30], its prognostic value in AF patients to initiate and guide sleep apnea treatment is unknown. We decided to focus on The AASM Scoring Manual recommended AHI definition in this manuscript and determined the diagnostic accuracy of oximetry derived ODI determined by our new algorithm to identify sleep apnea based on this AHI definition in AF patients.

  • Complications cardiovasculaires du syndrome d'apnées du sommeil: Cardiovascular complications of sleep apnea syndrome

    2017, Revue des Maladies Respiratoires Actualites
    Citation Excerpt :

    À partir de la cohorte des patients de la « Sleep Heart and Health Study », Vo et al. [8] ont évalué le retentissement de ces variations de seuil de désaturation en oxygène sur la sévérité des troubles respiratoires au cours du sommeil, mettant ainsi en évidence une différence d’IAH d’autant plus importante que les troubles respiratoires nocturnes étaient les moins sévères conduisant ainsi à une sous estimation de la gravité des patients à IAH faible pouvant éventuellement aboutir à sous évaluer l’intérêt d’un traitement chez ces patients. N. Punjabi (Baltimore, USA) a repris ces éléments à l’occasion d’un symposium (session A86) consacré à ce sujet en rappelant les résultats d’une étude récemment publiée à partir de 2 cohortes espagnoles portant sur 1116 femmes et 939 sujets âgés dont la sévérité des troubles respiratoires au cours du sommeil a été évaluée en fonction du seuil de désaturation et la présence éventuelle de micro-éveils [9]. Dans les 2 cohortes, l’utilisation de la définition de 2012 pour la détermination d’une hypopnée révélait une augmentation de 14 % de SAOS sévère (IAH > 30/h) par rapport à la définition ne tenant compte que d’une désaturation de 4 %.

  • Study of association of severity of sleep disordered breathing and functional outcome in stroke patients

    2017, Sleep Medicine
    Citation Excerpt :

    In our study, from India, we observed a similar rate of SDB in patients with stroke. Studies have reported a greater variation using different hypopnea definitions [22]. When we tried to use different criteria for defining hypopneas, we observed that the proportion of patients with severe SDB increased from 18% to 22%, and three patients were reclassified as having SDB by using the 3% desaturation limit instead of the 4% desaturation limit.

View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text